OpenIDEO is an open innovation platform. Join our global community to solve big challenges for social good. Sign Up / Login or Learn more

Prototyping for Election Accessibility, Part 1

Andrew Baranak is an industrial designer and research scientist at Georgia Tech Research Institute's Human Systems Integration Division. He's currently developing his iPad Absentee Voting idea which was a winner on our Voting Challenge.

Photo of OpenIDEO
9 6

Written by

Andrew Baranak was one of our winners on last year's Voting Challenge which asked How might we design an accessible election experience for everyone? Andrew is an industrial designer and research scientist at Georgia Tech Research Institute's Human Systems Integration Division. From there he works on a variety of human factors projects, with a primary focus on increased accessibility for people with physical impairments.

Andrew's iPad Absentee Voting idea began with his observation of the challenges that many folks have in placing their vote on election day. "Some people can't make it to poll booths during opening hours, others face various degrees of physical challenges which may be long term or recent. Although an absentee voting paper system already exists, it still does't serve all user groups to access their basic democratic right", he mentions. His initial winning concept on OpenIDEO focused on an iPad used for absentee voting either as a handheld device or mounted at a voting kiosk. However since the being awarded grant funding by our challenge sponsors, the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF), for further development of his project – he's been focusing on a case which could hold the iPad and deliver a number of additional accessibility features.

"Early focus groups with visually impaired informants turned up some real insights around how they actually experienced the voting procedure and also used devices like iPads. One woman told us she faced challenges at the polling station with poll workers not knowing quite what to do with her, though she was able to be helped by her husband. But her main desire was to vote on her own. Others told of how they had been able to learn how to use an iPad because of the Apple voiceover technology which allowed them to accomplish self-directed learning which was an adoption method they valued," reports Andrew. These human-centered insights lead to an increased sensitivity to the kind of drivers, barriers and opportunities as he proceeded with his project and exemplifies the designing with, not for approach which we're fans of here at OpenIDEO.

From here Andrew went on to make comprehensive artists renderings of four options of cases so he could make initial evaluations and comparisons across various accessibility criteria – such as simplicity of use, ease of manufacture, durability and versatility. "The process of detailed digital rendering forces you to think about specifics – like size, thickness, button size, textures and how they might effect interaction," he reflects. A report including the these visualisations has now gone out to election accessibility experts for feedback to help Andrew make a decision about which version to make a physical prototype of to test further with real users.

 

Feasibility testing of using the tactile controls with a sample iPad Ballot

 

While rendering has been a valuable part of Andrew's process so far, he adds, "you can visualise all you want – but until you get it into someone's hands you don't really know how things are going to go." He shows us a prototype from another project where different surfaces were placed on each side of a 3D model so users could report on which side felt the best. "You need people to hold, touch, feel and use your prototypes so that you can test your assumptions and iterate further," he adds. He's looking forward to embracing this essential phase of the project once initial feedback is in.

Keen to get a glimpse of some more details? Check out a couple of concept visualisations from the many Andrew has done for this project. He and his team at Georgia Tech continue to work on their iPad Absentee Voting pursuit and we hope to have future updates on their progress. 

 

 

 

9 comments

Join the conversation:

Comment
Spam
Photo of 먹튀검증의 새로운 패러다임

<a href="https://kipu.com.ua/noriteototo/" target="_blank">놀이터토토</a>Hello ! I am a student writing <a href="https://remarka.kz/meijeototo/" target="_blank">메이저토토</a> a report on the subject <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwi/" target="_blank">먹튀</a> of your post.<a href="https://kipu.com.ua/anjeongongwon/" target="_blank">안전공원</a> Your article is an article <a href="https://remarka.kz/totochucheon/" target="_blank">토토추천</a> with all the content and topics <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwigeomjeungchucheon/" target="_blank">먹튀검증추천</a> I've ever wanted <a href="https://remarka.kz/totosaiteuchucheon/" target="_blank">토토사이트추천</a>. Thanks to this, it will be of great help to the <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/anjeonmeijeo/" target="_blank">안전메이저</a> report I am preparing now. If you're okay <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwisaitpihanunbub/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트피하는법</a>, I'd like to close the report with a quote from you. If you have time later <a href="https://remarka.kz/totosaiteuchucheon/" target="_blank">토토사이트추천</a>, would you please stop by my blog and read the post I wrote? <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwigeomjeung2/ " target="_blank">먹튀검증</a>My blog has a lot of photos and articles on these topics.<a href="https://kipu.com.ua/anjeonhannoriteo-2/ " target="_blank">안전한놀이터</a> It might be helpful to you.<a href="https://remarka.kz/noliteototo/ " target="_blank">놀이터토토</a>

Spam
Photo of 먹튀검증의 새로운 패러다임

<a href="https://kipu.com.ua/" target="_blank">안전놀이터검증및연구센터</a> Hello, <a href="https://remarka.kz/" target="_blank">토토사이트분석전문블로그</a> your post was really impressive to me. <a href="https://subtitles.ee/" target="_blank">먹튀검증의새로운패러다임</a> I'm very happy <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/" target="_blank">https://kipu.com.ua/</a>to finally find the article <a href="https://remarka.kz/" target="_blank">https://remarka.kz/</a>I've been searching for. <a href="https://subtitles.ee/" target="_blank">https://subtitles.ee/</a>How did you write this article? <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwigeomjeung/" target="_blank">먹튀검증</a> That's amazing. <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/ahnjunnoritor/" target="_blank">안전놀이터</a> It is no exaggeration to <a href="https://remarka.kz/totositechucheon/" target="_blank">토토사이트</a> say that you are an expert <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwigeomjeungsite/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트검증</a> in this field. <a href="https://remarka.kz/hyeonmyeonghantotosaiteu/" target="_blank">메이저토토사이트</a> I want to <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/meijeoanjeonnoriteo/" target="_blank">메이저안전놀이터</a> learn how to <a href="https://remarka.kz/anjeonhansaseoltotosaiteu/" target="_blank">사설토토사이트</a> write from you. <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/gongsiganjeonnoriteo/" target="_blank">공식안전놀이터</a> Actually, <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwigeomjeungcommunity/" target="_blank">먹튀검증커뮤니티</a> I'm posting on <a href="https://remarka.kz/meogtwigeomjeungtotosaiteu/" target="_blank">검증사이트</a> a similar site. <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwigeomjeungtoto/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트</a>It's not really easy. <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/saseoranjeonnoriteo/" target="_blank">사설안전놀이터</a> That's why I think you're even greater. COVID-19 is a problem around the world these days. Are you okay? I would like to thank you again for always being careful and allowing me to read this. Then have a happy day. Thank you. It will be of great <a href="https://remarka.kz/geomjeungtotosaiteu/" target="_blank">사설토토</a> help to me. Anyway, have a nice day <a href="https://subtitles.ee/anjeonhanmeogtwigeomjeung/" target="_blank">먹튀중개소</a> today and thank you for your hard work. <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/choegouianjeonnoriteo/" target="_blank">최고의안전놀이터</a>Nowadays,<a href="https://remarka.kz/totosaiteugeomjeungeobche/" target="_blank">토토</a> the weather is getting colder every day<a href="https://kipu.com.ua/totoanjeonnoriteo/" target="_blank">토토안전놀이터</a>, so wear warm clothes and watch out for a cold <a href="https://subtitles.ee/hwaksilhanmeogtwigeomjeung/" target="_blank">먹튀</a> My field <a href="https://remarka.kz/anjeonhantotosaiteu/" target="_blank">안전한토토사이트</a> of interest seems to be very similar to me <a href="https://kipu.com.ua/anjeonhannoriteo/" target="_blank">안전한놀이터</a>, so I keep looking for more articles. <a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwisaitgeomjeung/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트검증</a> In addition, there are interesting topics <a href="https://remarka.kz/meijeosaseoltotosaiteu/" target="_blank">메이저사설토토사이트</a> and discussions going on on my site,<a href="https://kipu.com.ua/noriteochucheon/" target="_blank">놀이터추천</a> like the author wrote, so please visit us anytime.<a href="https://subtitles.ee/meogtwisingo/" target="_blank">먹튀검증</a>

Spam
Photo of 먹튀검증의 새로운 패러다임

<a href="https://elephonemobile.com/" target="_blank">토토사이트</a> Nice to meet you. <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/" target="_blank">먹튀검증</a> I run a site that uploads posts similar to yours. <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/meogtwigeomgeoyul1wisite/" target="_blank">먹튀</a> Your post is really different. <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/jigusangeseogajanghwagsilhanmeogtwigeomjeungeobche/" target="_blank">먹튀검증업체</a> I really enjoyed reading it. <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/mideulsuissneunmeogtwisite/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트</a> What did you think of this post? That's great. I wish I had your writing skills. I envy you. It's not enough for you <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/meijeoanjeonnoliteochucheon/" target="_blank">안전한놀이터</a>, but there's a lot uploaded <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/jigusangeseogajanganjeonhanmeijeonoliteo/" target="_blank">메이저놀이터</a> on my site. There are also uploaded contents that you may be interested in, <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/category/anjeonnoliteo/" target="_blank">안전놀이터</a> so please visit and read them and leave your comments. I'd be very happy if you could. I think it'll help me a lot <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/saseolnoliteo/" target="_blank">놀이터토토</a>. Anyway, <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/jachegeomjeungwanlyochoegouianjeonnoliteo/" target="_blank">안전놀이터</a> thank you again for allowing me to read these posts <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/meijeototosite/" target="_blank">메이저토토사이트</a> and I will visit your website often. Well, <a href="https://elephonemobile.com/totositechucheon/" target="_blank">토토사이트추천</a> thank you very much<a href="https://elephonemobile.com/" target="_blank">토토레프리</a> . Goodbye!<a href="https://elephonemobile.com/" target="_blank">https://elephonemobile.com/</a>

Spam
Photo of 먹튀검증의 새로운 패러다임

Your article was very impressive to me. <a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">먹튀검증</a>It was unexpected information,<a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">안전놀이터</a>but after reading it like this,<a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">토토사이트</a> I found it very interesting. <a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">꽁머니</a>Thank you very much. it was an honor to see this information. I should upload similar information on my website. Come and check it out for me. In addition, COVID-19 is becoming a problem <a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트조회</a> all over the world these days. I hope there's no harm to you and your family. <a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">먹튀가디언</a> Thank you<a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">https://twiddeo.com/</a> Nowadays,<a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">검증업체</a> the weather is getting colder every day, so wear warm clothes <a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">먹튀사이트</a> and watch out for a cold <a href="https://twiddeo.com/" target="_blank">먹튀검증사이트</a> Your post <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">토토사이트</a> will be of great help <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">안전놀이터</a> to the post <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">먹튀검증</a> I was preparing. I would like to add your opinion <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">먹튀요기요</a> to my post <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">https://mtygy.com/</a> in the future, so would you please <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">먹튀</a> visit my site once? <a href="https://mtygy.com/" target="_blank">사설토토</a>

Spam
Photo of Benjamin Balling

While I absolutely support the idea of making elections for accessible, I have serious concerns about using technology in its current state. This YouTube video does a great job explaining the many issues surrounding it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI). I believe we simply need to expand the voting period as many states have done with early voting. There is simply no reason that it needs to be on the first Tuesday after the first Monday of November since we are no longer an agrarian society reliant on horse and carriage.

Spam
Photo of Sarah Fathallah

Such an awesome realisation update. Way to go Andrew!

Spam
Photo of DeletedUser

DeletedUser

Thank you!

Spam
Photo of Priyanka Kodikal

How cool! Congratulations on realizing your concept!

Spam
Photo of DeletedUser

DeletedUser

Thanks a ton!