Scaling up Forward Incubator's impact to other European cities
Forward empowers refugees to achieve economic independence through entrepreneurship and to integrate into host societies
What problem does the idea help to solve and how does your solution work? (2,000 characters maximum)
Forward Incubator supports entrepreneurs with a refugee background in starting a new business, hereby becoming successful in their host country and being able to integrate into the community. We focus on the group of people in Western Europe that have the following characteristics:
Residence permit based on asylum or an asylum-seeker awaiting residence permit
People that are at the forefront of refugee communities: we focus on highly-educated newcomers that speak English will and that bear a lot of potential for contribution to the local economies. These people can uplift their families and communities through their enterprises, work and established networks
We focus on newcomers with a refugee background in urban areas with an ambition to become an entrepreneur
Newcomers lack opportunity to be successful in entrepreneurship or to find access to the labour market. This problem consists of several root causes:
Newcomers lack access to a social and professional network
Newcomers miss a full grasp of local culture, language and expected behaviour in a professional network
Newcomers lack access to capital
Newcomers lack knowledge of legal and fiscal systems
Many newcomers have lost the confidence in their own talents and skills
Forward Incubator addresses all of these challenges through a methodology in which we provide:
Coaching by experienced entrepreneurs
Support from university students
Access to a network of companies and investors
Facilitation of relationship with municipalities
We have a 4-month program in which 30 entrepreneurs can enter our introductory period of 3 weeks. Below is described the different phases through which entrepreneurs go.
Geography of focus (500 characters)
We target urban areas; this is where entrepreneurship is key to develop stable livelihoods and self-reliance for refugees. We have identified four European cities(Stockholm, Frankfurt, Hamburg, Berlin) with the right conditions for the implementation of our program: a large and diverse refugee population; a positive context towards refugees; a thriving entrepreneurial community; a solid presence of corporates; and a network of universities. Read our feasibility study - https://bit.ly/2z1XpO8
Building Bridges: What bridge does your idea build between people on the move and neighbors towards a shared future of stability and promise? (500 characters)
First, we focus on changing the public and personal perception of refugees from a dependent group to active members of the community who have potential, good ideas and experiences that contribute to the local economy and society with their entrepreneurial ventures. Second, we integrate local and refugee populations by putting them to work together; these shared experiences lead to cultural exchanges, empathy development and better understanding of each other’s stories and backgrounds.
What human need is your idea solving for? (1,000 characters)
We believe that in the process of pursuing an entrepreneurial endeavor and with every milestone reached, the refugees that we work with strengthen their sense of self-worth and pride (dignity). Furthermore, we view our members as entrepreneurs who have autonomy and ownership over their businesses and lives even if the rest of the world sees them as refugees.
Along our program the entrepreneurs are encouraged to envision fulfilling lives for themselves and their families, to work towards challenging and rewarding goals, and to pursue their aspirations or develop new ones (hope). Moreover, we aim to create joy within our entrepreneurs by giving them a place to belong to, nurturing their potential, making their work fun, and welcoming their diverse perspectives; all with the goal to enable their wellbeing.
What will be different within the community of focus as a result of implementing your idea? (1,000 characters)
Forward Incubator is strongly committed to achieve a tangible and measurable impact for the people it supports. We are measuring a variety of indicators that show that we make impact on the level of the individual, our community and society. For the individual participants, we expect to achieve:
60% of participants start a business
75% is full-time employed or full-time entrepreneur after graduation
For our community, we achieve:
More than 50 professionals involved in a single program
More than 30 university students involved per program
For society, we achieve:
Recurring savings on social benefits of 170.000 euros per program for 15 participants
1.8 million in economic value added through created jobs
What is the inspiration behind your idea? (1,000 characters)
Our inspiration comes from the entrepreneurs we have been working with for the past 2 years, in them we have witnessed a strong desire to succeed, a relentless commitment to their goals, and a great deal of personal development and growth as they emerge from our program with confidence and tools to take ownership of their lives in the new cities where they find themselves. We aspire to bring the same effect to refugees in the the other geographies that we have identified with high potential.
Furthermore, we find inspiration in the community that supports our work - the corporate partners that share their knowledge and increase the capacity of our entrepreneurs; the coaches who guide the development of our members and help them avoid pitfalls; the volunteers who are heavily involved and help our entrepreneurs to navigate the local context; and the local governments that enable our impact by integrating us into their local ecosystems and by offering access to other services.
Describe the dynamics of the community in which the idea is to be implemented. (1,000 characters)
Our program community to support 15 entrepreneurs consists of several trainers, 15 business coaches, 30 university students and a network of companies, investors and advisors. Further, we work with incubator networks such as university incubators and the major co-working spaces in Amsterdam and Rotterdam.
Our trainers come from top entrepreneurship institutes such as the Amsterdam Center for Entrepreneurship, Innoleaps and Firmhouse. These trainers also train and coach startups at accelerators such as Startupbootcamp and Rockstart.
Our coaches are mostly experienced entrepreneurs. They are matched 1-on-1 with the entrepreneurs and coach them on average 2 hours a week.
Each entrepreneur is matched with 2 university students that support on average 10 hours in writing a business plan and all elements of the business operations.
We expose entrepreneurs to a network of corporate companies including Uber, Mazars, Deloitte, Linklaters, DLA Piper, SThree, Dentons, McKinsey &
How does your idea leverage and empower community strengths and assets to help create an environment for success? (1,000 characters)
Our community is successful because of the extreme diversity in terms of nationalities, educational background and profession. The focus of programs is on that what unites all these people, which is a belief in entrepreneurship as a force for self-reliance, innovation and integration.
What other partners or stakeholders will work alongside you in implementing the idea, if any? (1,000 characters)
Cambridge Innovation Center
McKinsey & Company
Incubators in target locations Stockholm, Frankfurt, Hamburg, Berlin
Municipalities in target locations
Universities in target locations
What part of the displacement journey is your solution addressing
Arriving and settling at a destination community
Tell us how you'd describe the type of innovation you are proposing
Service: A new or enhanced service that creates value for end beneficiaries
Idea Proposal Stage
Majority Adoption: We have expanded the pilot significantly and the program product or service has been adopted by the majority of our intended user base (i.e. 50% to 83% of the target population or 50,000 to 1,000,000 users).
Group or Organization Name
Forward Incubator programs are organized by the Refugees Forward Foundation, registered in Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Tell us more about your group or organization [or lived experience as a displaced person?] (1000 characters)
Our organization is solely focused on refugee entrepreneurship. In the past 2 years we have built up substantial knowledge in the area of training, coaching and supporting refugee entrepreneurs. We understand the challenges and are considerate with the personal circumstances. However, we hold the entrepreneurs in our program to the same standard as other businesses out there.
As an organization, we provide a young and spirited team that takes on challenges of nowadays and is not afraid to be bold and take risks. Further, we are supported by expert professionals in our advisory board in all relevant areas of businesses. We have a deep reach in the target community through Word of Mouth, connections with refugee organizations, online marketing campaigns and connections with municipalities.
We have the capacity to grow and currently have 5fte and 3 interns working alongside us.
Type of submitter
We are a registered Non-Profit Organization
Organization Headquarters: Country
Organization Headquarters: City / State
In preparation for expert feedback: What are three unanswered questions or challenges that you could use support on in these categories? These questions will be answered directly by experts matched specifically to your idea. (600 characters)
1. How can we validate the data gathered in our in initial feasibility study to ensure that the contextual components needed for expansion are available in each potential city for expansion? You can find our initial report at https://bit.ly/2z1XpO8
2. How to better understand the local landscape of donor and philanthropic organizations that could help us to secure funding in each city?
3. What are the main considerations when adapting or replicating an existing model into a new context?
Did you use the resources offered during the Improve Phase (mentorship, expert feedback, community research)? (2000 characters)
Every entrepreneur gets a dedicated team that supports the development of their business idea.
We had a great call with our coach. She evaluated our initiative from her perspective of a newcomer and during our conversation Maisara determined that our initiative covers well several of the needs of newcomers: legal navigation, empowerment, livelihood generation and breaking social stigmas. Her comments were largely positive and allowed us to validate that our initiative has strong elements of desirability for our target group.
At the same time, it became clear to us that to improve the desirability of our program we must strengthen our capabilities to support our program participants with mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, lack of confidence, trauma, etc.
Although we are not mental health experts, some of our team members are now being trained on mental health topics to allow us to determine when someone could benefit from professional interventions, and at the same time, we are working to build partnerships with mental health organizations that can support newcomers, in order to offer the possibility to our program participants of getting mental health support.
We also had the chance to have a very productive conversation with another organization participating in this challenge; Five One Labs. They are a business incubator in Kurdistan Region of Iraq with a very similar mission to ours, but with a different approach. Therefore this conversation was a great exchange of best practices, a positive validation about our model from an expert in the same field, and a source of inspiration to adopt new mechanisms that could create great value for our entrepreneurs, such as a peer-to-peer support system for program graduates and potentially developing a new program that would seek an even stronger connection between starting local and newcomer entrepreneurs (currently we only work with newcomers with experienced local entrepreneurs as coaches).
In what ways would potential BridgeBuilder funds allow you to pursue your idea that other funding opportunities have not? (1000 characters)
Since OpenIDEO and the GHR Foundation are organizations that support social innovation internationally, we are expecting these funds to give us the necessary financial resources to scale up Forward Incubator’s impact by reaching more newcomer populations in other European cities. Our current funding partners support us with the intention of financing our activities and impact in the Netherlands, which has enabled us greatly but at the same time restricts our possibilities to have an international presence.
In the next sections we outline the areas in which the funds would support our initiative; but in summary these financial resources would be used for the following purposes:
-Piloting program and and building networks in new european cities.
-Building a team and running the first full incubation program in one new location
-Partially funding the second full program in the new location.
What aspects or proportion of the overall idea would potential BridgeBuilder funds primarily support? (1000 characters)
There are 3 stages in the expansion process of Forward Incubator towards new cities. For each of these we will outline the activities, budget and expenses and expected sourcing of funds. See attached excel file in application for more detail.
1. Preparation, testing and building the network (38K USD financed by BB): until June 20
Focus of the first stage is on validating assumptions. In this phase we organize a Startup Day to test these assumptions.
- 2K travel
- 6K event
2. First Incubator program (120K USD financed by BB): sept 20 - jan 21
- 30K management
- 5K international travel
- 68K program
- 12K rent
- 5K business development
3. 2nd program + onwards: Feb 21 - onwards
120K budget financed by:
- 42K BridgeBuilders
- 58K Local Grants
- 20K Companies
What are the key steps or activities for your idea for implementation in the next 1-3 years? (1000 characters)
1. Piloting (until June 2020)
Our first goal is to organize a Startup Day (June 2020) in which we test locally. This Startup Day brings together 10 local entrepreneurs, 10 students and 10 business coaches for 1 day. They undergo 2 trainings and have multiple coaching moments. At night they present their idea.
2. Learnings and adaptations to new context (July-August 2020)
In this phase we assess local contexts (rules and regulation, economic factors, difference in target group) and tweak our program to fit the local context.
3. First full program (Sept 2020 - January 2021)
First 4 month incubator program for 15 newcomers
4. Achieving sustainability: running 2 full programs per year (Feb 2021 -onwards)
- Strong team
- Strong local partners
- Financial health
- Network rooted in community (end-user)
What will community-level impact look like over the timeframe of your idea? How will you determine whether or not you have achieved that impact? And what outstanding questions do you still have? (1000 characters)
I: By 2022 we aim to: reach 800 newcomers in Europe, serve 350 entrepreneurs yearly, have 400 incubated businesses with paying customers and have 10+ business with €100K in revenue.
To achieve this we must run the first full program in a new location in 2020 (validate scale up model), and then expand to 4 more locations by 2022.
M: We measure the number of newcomers reached and businesses launched, and also evaluate their improvements on human, social and financial capital. These are a mix of business metrics (revenue, profit, etc) and human indicators (self-confidence, community integration, wealth, etc.)
Q: How to understand the local landscape of donor and philanthropic organizations to secure funding in each city? Although we aim to be 40% self-reliant by 2022, we will require external funding to achieve our impact.
Describe the individual or team that will implement this idea (if a partnership, please explain breakdown of roles and responsibilities for each entity). (1000 characters)
Our management team consists of Laura Di Santolo (program director) and Diederick van der Wijk (managing director).
For a new program, we will need a program manager and support from interns as a program team. The local team further needs to create capacity for business development and needs support from our program director. We expect 2 FTE + support of interns will suffice to open up a new location.
Our team is supported by a strong advisory board of investment fund managers and incubator and accelerator founders, among which Floris van Alkemade, Erik Boer, Don Ritzen, Mirjam van Praag, Megha Mittal. Find out more on our website about their involvement https://bit.ly/2MhJA5v
Lastly, how did you apply new learnings to your idea? (1000 characters)
The expert brought to our attention that we must make some program elements more explicit and work on others.
For our approach to be successful, the legal frameworks must enable newcomers to pursue entrepreneurship by providing freedom of mobility, financial stability and allowing their long-term stay in the host countries (residence, citizenship, etc).
We must understand the potential contextual limitations in each target city. To bridge our knowledge gaps we are in contact with local organizations and municipalities that have broad perspectives on legal frameworks, service availability and business ecosystems. We will meet some of them at the Refugee Entrepreneurship Summit 2019 in London this month. We will also use this opportunity to validate the feasibility of our program with the same organizations; hopefully they will have relevant and constructive feedback to ensure the implementation of our initiative.