OpenIDEO is an open innovation platform. Join our global community to solve big challenges for social good. Sign Up / Login or Learn more

Top Manta Project: Nobody is illegal

An ethical, social and solidarity brand that is committed to changing this society by improving the lives of the most vulnerable.

Photo of Top Manta Project
81 98

Written by

What problem does the idea help to solve and how does your solution work? (2,000 characters maximum)

Current legislation in Spain and institutional racism prevent migrant people fleeing their home countries, whether due to poverty, war, violence or persecution, from accessing legal and decent work. We are migrants and we are people of peace; we risk our own lives fleeing from our countries in order to have a decent job and help our families to survive. Upon arrival to Spain, our dreams are broken, we are treated as criminals, imprisoned or deported and considered ‘migrants in irregular situation’, not having the right to residence and work, neither access to basic social services such as education, housing and health. In order to regularize our situation, we are required to remain in Spain for at least 3 years, but we have no right to work. In order to survive, we work as street vendors, but it is considered an illegal activity and when we are detained by the police, this criminal record prevents our regularization for another 5 years. We are thus trapped by the system, which prevents us from having a decent job and criminalizes us, being the constant target of the police, politicians and the media. That is why in 2015 we join together as a Labor Union and launch our own Top Manta clothing brand to give voice to our situation of injustice, persecution and vulnerability, to find ourselves a solution to our labor problem, to improve our living conditions collectively and fight together for legislative changes. With our self-management project, we offer labor opportunities to our colleagues through an offer of a one-year pre-contract to those who have been in Spain for 3 years so that they can apply for a work and residence permit by the way of 'social roots' and can work on the project; we can also offer a scholarship training program for those colleagues living less than 3 years in Spain. The creation of employment by Top Manta project for people who exercise street sales in our city, allows its administrative regularization and participation in the territory.

Geography of focus (500 characters)

Our project has as main objective to continue looking for collective solutions for the problems faced by the more than 400 street vendors living in Barcelona (Spain), not only labor, but also legal, housing, training, etc. For this, it is essential to regularize our administrative situation. We believe that this project model can be extended globally to all vulnerable migrant groups in the world. This is how we understand self-management: political innovation for a more just and hopeful horizon.

Building Bridges: What bridge does your idea build between people on the move and neighbors towards a shared future of stability and promise? (500 characters)

The project means a breakthrough for the normalization and integration of the migrant community within the city of Barcelona. The project has allowed the Popular Labor Union of Street Vendors to dignify our work, register our own logo and create our own business, with which we want to regularize the administrative situation of all the street vendors that live in Barcelona, integrate them into the city, make aware to the population on our current problem, eliminate discriminatory laws and racism.

What human need is your idea solving for? (1,000 characters)

Top Manta project was born as a model of self-management and social transformation. According to the calculations, in Barcelona, for more than 10 years a group of between 400 street vendors remain permanently. The majority are young people from African countries, mainly Senegal. Top Manta project pursues the right to a dignified life and to get a job from the legal point of view. We want to demonstrate our capabilities and what we are worth, we want to work legally to contribute to the economy of our city, Barcelona. Since our creation we have achieved the regularization and integration of 85 colleagues through our struggle. We believe 'Nobody is Illegal' and thus through our brand and our activities we also want to eliminate racism and get the necessary support from society and political groups to modify the current legislation that discriminates against the poorest and most vulnerable collectives.

What will be different within the community of focus as a result of implementing your idea? (1,000 characters)

The greatest achievement has been the elimination of stigma of our collective: now people ask what is behind the blanket. We are not only vendors, there is much more and people have lost their fear of asking us about our lives. A breakthrough for the normalization and integration of the migrant community within the city of Barcelona. When we launched the brand everyone was surprised. The essential thing has been the brand, but the fact that we have shown that we have capacity, that we are entrepreneurs and creative. People started then asking us for t-shirts, they wanted to buy Top Manta products and we didn't even have the resources to make them. As the project developed, we have managed to open our own shop-workshop in the Raval neighborhood of Barcelona (Spain). At present, our work is mainly serigraphy, sewing, both design and production of > 4,000 pieces/year of clothing. In addition, our group sees in the brand an opportunity to continue evolving towards social integration.

What is the inspiration behind your idea? (1,000 characters)

Through our activities and our clothing brand Top Manta we want to make our situation known and that society sees us as we deserve, as what we really are: fighters, workers, with trades and with the desire to work without be daily harassed by the police. We are people who have put at risk our lives to access a honest and legal work. Thanks to the selfless support of PlayGround Do. the group of vendors created in 2017 our own line of designs, with which we narrate our trip in dinghy puting in risk our lives to the Spanish coast, the fight for our rights and the link we maintain with the culture of Africa. Likewise, we wanted our clothes to be of quality and represent our values, that is why we use environmentally friendly fabrics (such as Fair Trade cotton and recycled materials of the Continental Clothing brand) and also respect the labor rights of those who make them. ‘Legal clothing made by illegal people’ is the leit motiv of our collection.

Describe the dynamics of the community in which the idea is to be implemented. (1,000 characters)

Our project has as main objective to continue looking for collective solutions for the problems faced by the more than 400 street vendors living in Barcelona, not only labor, but also legal, housing, training, etc. For this, it is essential to regularize our administrative situation. Becoming a Cooperative would allow us to enter into employment contracts for those who still cannot access them, to improve our working conditions and generate the possibility of hiring as many colleagues as possible. Not only to find work solutions but because work is the main way to acquire residence and work permits in Spain. At present, our work is mainly serigraphy, sewing, both design and production and sale of our own garments. However, our idea is to expand the possibilities of self-employment so that colleagues who have trades and knowledge can apply them in some type of service, promoting the presence of migrants in the cooperative world and favoring the development of a global social market.

How does your idea leverage and empower community strengths and assets to help create an environment for success? (1,000 characters)

In the last year, the demand for Top Manta products has begun to grow and so has the interest of designers and other agents in the fashion world. We managed to open our own shop-workshop in the Raval neighborhood (Barcelona) and also acquired the necessary machines for screen printing. Our project is based on a code of common values: work and solidarity between us & with other vulnerable groups. Therefore, we believe that a commercial activity can have a social&solidarity function. We are committed to offering ecological, fair trade products and affordable screen printing prices; mainly, because groups and associations can screen their t-shirts/pieces. Likewise, our store is designed not only as a commercial space but above all as a meeting space, where different knowledge and needs are socialized in talks. We are convinced that promoting the presence of migrants in the cooperative world favors a sustainable development from an anti-racist perspective and improves the social market.

What other partners or stakeholders will work alongside you in implementing the idea, if any? (1,000 characters)

A key moment for the group was the strategic alliance with PlayGround Do., carried out for one year (June 2017 - June 2018). The art department of the digital platform participated, as well as 15 professionals from different disciplines: sociologists, activists, political scientists, lawyers, designers, philosophers, artists, teachers and filmmakers. The initiative had a three-phase strategy: training (legal advice, marketing, branding and business), creation of a micro patronage through the crowfounding platform and the creation of the business and communication (presentation of the collection on a fashion show to sell our items and make ourselves known to the general public through the media). We have also had the constant support from “Tras la Manta” and “Espacio del Inmigrante” (local organizations) and free legal advice from Rizoma Lawyers, with whom we have designed a first phase of activity in the fashion sector towards our long-term objective: the creation our own Cooperative.

What part of the displacement journey is your solution addressing

  • Arriving and settling at a destination community

Tell us how you'd describe the type of innovation you are proposing

  • Service: A new or enhanced service that creates value for end beneficiaries

Idea Proposal Stage

  • Early Adoption: We have completed a pilot and analyzed the impact of that pilot on the intended users of the idea. I have proof of user uptake (i.e. 16% to 49% of the target population or 1,000 to 50,000 users).

Group or Organization Name

The Popular Labor Union of Street Vendors of Barcelona, Spain (Sindicato Popular de Vendedores Ambulantes de Barcelona)

Tell us more about your group or organization [or lived experience as a displaced person?] (1000 characters)

Our non-profit association is composed of migrants and racialized people as a collective that experienced displacement. We work permanently in the anti-racist struggle, to denounce and combat racism and colonialism. Our project is aimed at overcoming the exclusion suffered by our collective. Street vendors are victims of multiple discriminations: because of our race and class, because of the work we do and our socioeconomic status (such as housing, access to resources, etc.). Top Manta cooperative allows us to overcome the situation of the street that violates and criminalizes us, creating a space of security and common work, in which collectively we can create answers to the various problems that concern us. Our project and self-management model has begun to be implemented in other cities in Spain and we believe that it can inspire all vulnerable groups and extend to all countries of the world, so that migrants can work and reside legally in the country to which they migrate.

Website URL:

http://manteros.org/ https://www.instagram.com/topmanta_bcn/ https://www.facebook.com/SindicatoPopulardeVendedoresAmbulantes/ https://twitter.com/sindicatomanter

Type of submitter

  • We are a Cooperative or Community-Owned Organization

Organization Headquarters: Country

Spain

Organization Headquarters: City / State

Barcelona (Barcelona)

In preparation for expert feedback: What are three unanswered questions or challenges that you could use support on in these categories? These questions will be answered directly by experts matched specifically to your idea. (600 characters)

- How could we improve the message we want to give society to ensure that it understands the objective of our idea and the bridges we are building with the local community through our project? - What tactics or means do you advise us that we could use in the future to get our message and our idea goals to reach the world globally? - How do you advise us that we could raise society's awareness of our problem and achieve legislative changes in institutions that prevent discrimination against migrants and promote equality policies? - What alliances we could establish to increase our impact?

Did you use the resources offered during the Improve Phase (mentorship, expert feedback, community research)? (2000 characters)

Mentorship: we had a very constructive meeting with our assigned mentor, Tawfiq Abbud, that help us to identify some áreas that might be clarified in our idea. We learned how valuable is our idea and how it can change the lives of a lot of people, not only to our collective here in Spain but around the world as a model of self-management and advocacy that will inspire many other vulnerable groups globally. We have learned how important is to show to the community: the process how we plan to solve the legal status of the migrants (including statistics about the work we have done and how many lives we can change in a given time period if we get the funding), the legal journey for migrants in irregular situation and how is the process to get a legal work/residence permission in Spain and the connection we have with the local business and community through our project and activities. We have edited our idea adding new information & images and a complete business plan to include all this information. Experts feedback: from the valuable answers obtained from our expert (Swatee Deepak), we have learned that although we are currently carrying out many of the proposed initiatives (i.e collaborations with local students, artists, fashion designers, NGOs saving lives in the sea, attendance at European events such as City Rights United events and Permanent People's Tribunal) we can continue to improve and strengthen these collaborations to raise our message worldwide and achieve legislative changes. Community research: during the improve phase we have shared our idea to the migrant and local community through our social networks and we have organized an event with our local neighbours in Barcelona were we showed our project and our fight for our human rights. The comments and stories learned during this phase demonstrated a positive mentality change in our collective and the community as bridges are built as a benefit for all.

In what ways would potential BridgeBuilder funds allow you to pursue your idea that other funding opportunities have not? (1000 characters)

BridgeBuilder funds would be essential for us to develop the brand globally and reach our objectives: increase the production/sales of the brand's products in the online shop, the sale to other local business/spaces enabled in social events/fairs, increase our presence in human rights events, schools/universities, and to reach >140 street vendors contracted directly by the project and through our struggle getting occupational plans by the city council with laboral contracts of at least 1 year duration and achieve legislative changes against immigrants discriminatory laws. For this we would need to have a wider space to store the products, expand the silkscreen equipments, garments and sewing workshop, and have our own transport vehicles ($100K). It would also allow us to offer labor contracts to street vendors in our multi-service cooperative and implement advocacy & cooperation initiatives ($100K). The overall funding needed to accomplish these objectives is $200K.

What aspects or proportion of the overall idea would potential BridgeBuilder funds primarily support? (1000 characters)

BridgeBuilder funds could allow us to legalize a greater number of people in an irregular situation offering job opportunities and training scholarships and continue creating bridges for their inclusion, protection and recognition. The funds would also be used to make the brand more competitive in the fashion world to expand the brand and our message globally, also to have the necessary resources to participate in activities and events globally at universities/administration for the formulation of policies that can make a difference in the fight against poverty, inequality and the fulfillment of human rights in the world. We want to launch the 'International Day against Inmigration Laws'. With the funds, we would also want to set up cooperative projects with the farmers of our country of origin (Senegal) to contribute to its development and the end of poverty in Senegal.

What are the key steps or activities for your idea for implementation in the next 1-3 years? (1000 characters)

Our main activity will be to continue looking for collective solutions to the problems faced by the > 400 street vendors that live in Barcelona, not only labor, but also legal, housing, training, etc., regularize their administrative situation and integrate it into the city, raise awareness to the population about our current problem, continue strengthening bridges with the local community, eliminate racism and get the necessary support from society and political groups to modify the legislation that discriminates against the poorest and most vulnerable groups. Currently, through our struggle and our project we have achieved the regularization and work permit of 85 colleagues. Our goal is to achieve the regulation of 35-40 colleagues more to be contracted directly through our project by 2021 and cooperate with the local administration to establish occupation plans that involve labor contracts of at least one year duration for another ≥ 100 street vendors by 2021.

What will community-level impact look like over the timeframe of your idea? How will you determine whether or not you have achieved that impact? And what outstanding questions do you still have? (1000 characters)

IMPACT: By 2021, our goal is to achieve the regularization of ≥140 street vendors. Continue building bridges with local community: integrate our collective into society and modify the current legislation that discriminates against the poorest and most vulnerable collectives. Launch globally the ‘International Day Against Inmigration Laws’. Have our project as a model of self-management and advocacy that inspire many other vulnerable groups globally. MEASUREMENT: We will measure the number of colleagues that get their regularization through our project and struggle. We will also measure the number of followers in our social networks and events to measure the ties with the local community, inspire other vulnerable groups globally and change discriminatory laws. QUESTIONS: How can we work with the youth community of our origin country to prevent them from risking their lives and leaving their families behind in order to have a better life and eliminate poverty?

Describe the individual or team that will implement this idea (if a partnership, please explain breakdown of roles and responsibilities for each entity). (1000 characters)

The Labor Union is made up of more than150 members. There are 9 members who work and collaborate actively in the association and the Top Manta Project mainly in the following activities: design, sewing, screen printing and sale of our own fashion garments and other products (t-shirts, sweatshirt, bags, caps, among other accessories), as well as screen printing services. Training services and talks aimed at entities, groups, schools and in the public administration: training in African culture, anti-racism and in the rights of migrants. Social and volunteers networks, communication with the press and with other groups/human risghts associations/local commerces/artists/fashion designers. Organization of group trips to Senegal for cultural exchange and Senegalese food services, mainly in popular festivals, political, cultural meetings, etc. Please watch our video to know us better, learn about our history and what the Top Manta Project means to us.

Lastly, how did you apply new learnings to your idea? (1000 characters)

Thanks to the valuable comments of our mentor and expert, we have realized of the value of our idea and how it can help other vulnerable groups in the world, but we have also learned how important it is to know how to properly communicate our message to all our audiences and thus achieve a social transformation in the world. Thus, we have edited our idea to explain&make visual how is the legal journey for migrants in Spain and how we can solve the problem, how our brand and activities are integrating the collective within the society and our legal advocay activities to change legislation. We also added a complete business plan to our idea to include all this information. The community research showed to us how the project is helping migrants of the collective and that we are also building robust bridges with the local community, that participate not only by buying our products but also in our fight for a social transformation, making them participants of a global change.

View more

Team (3)

Top Manta's profile
Agustín's profile
Agustín Ortiz Herrera

Role added on team:

"Agustín Ortiz Herrera is an artist and activist from the local community (Barcelona, Spain); he has collaborated since the beginning with the project, being our inspiration and designer of the Top Manta logo, which made possible the beginning of the brand and our entire project, helping us also throughout the brand presentation process. Agustín has been by our side helping us in many processes and is currently collaborating with us in the project to help us to launch a new brand shoe product."

Cristian's profile
Cristian Palazzi

Role added on team:

"Cristian Palazzi (Director of PlayGround Do), is a philosopher, teacher and social activist of the local community (Barcelona, Spain). Thanks to the selfless support of Cristian and PlayGround Do. we managed to turn our initiative into a long-term entrepreneurship project. Cristian also helped us throughout the process of launching a crowdfounding, presenting the brand in a fashion show, the Graphite Pencil prize at the D&AD Impact Awards and is currently helping us launch new project designs."

81 comments

Join the conversation:

Comment
Photo of Swatee Deepak
Team

1. How could we improve the message we want to give society to ensure that it understands the objective of our idea and the bridges we are building with the local community through our project?

I think the message you’ve already got is very powerful - No one is illegal.

I would expand on this so it’s easier to grasp for all your audiences - the individual/public, government, critics and allies. Go through who you need to convince, what you want them to hear and go from there.

A way of doing this is having more case studies of the people who Top Manta is made up of and for. Showing how relatable their stories are to everyone else, e.g. having a desire to learn, to get opportunities, to live healthy and in safety, to be able to eat, to be alongside friends and family, to succeed but that factors beyond their control have stopped that - war, poverty, persecution.

You can then go onto explain some of the journey’s people went through to get to Spain, the relief of getting to Spain and wanting to be part of the beautiful city but what the realities have been, discrimination, racism etc. The case studies could then include what being part of Top Manta has meant for them: finding hope, community, solidarity, support, regaining dignity and reigniting hope.

The case studies can be on film, online, in print or social media and be able to reach different audiences.

I appreciate this is sensitive information so you can anonymise or change people’s names and not have photographs of people’s faces.

2. What tactics or means do you advise us that we could use in the future to get our message and our idea goals to reach the world globally?

Network with as many people as possible to get the message out and build support and solidarity for your work. My advice is always to focus your attention on supporting the immprovement of your work and the people you work with and share those stories to inspire networks globally.

You have so many stakeholders you can reach out to about your work, here are a few ideas:

Students - Can you speak to students at the local universities and colleges about your work? Maybe they can run fundraisers, amplify the stories of the cause, support in raising awareness and on your advocacy work to get local, national or international governments and decision makes to take more notice.

Fashion - There is a huge movement on sustainable fashion linked to rights of works and climate change caused by fast fashion. You already have links in the fashion industry - continue to nurture and speak to your contacts in those places, speak about your work in teh context of climate change, of worker rights, as anti-racist approachs.

NGOs - There will be NGOs who want to support your network of street vendors, those campaigning for refugee and migrants rights, access to healthcare and essential services. Look at how you can connect to them and build partnerships and alliances - the more associations you have, the more your message can grow.

Migrants rights networks - Do the same as above with networks, such as joining the European Network of Innovation and Inclusion. The more voices supporting you, the more people can hear it.

Continue doing the amazing work you do!

3. How do you advise us that we could raise society's awareness of our problem and achieve legislative changes in institutions that prevent discrimination against migrants and promote equality policies?

I think the work you are doing is already amazing. The messages and support seem to be helping to amplify your work and the needs of your movement but I understand Top Manta needs to continue to build momentum and voice for greater changes, such as legislative.

I think the case studies, mentioned above would help, together with data on who you are supporting, their ages, dependants, the types of exploitation they’ve been subjected to in terms of access to state sanctioned services: education, healthcare and housing.

It’s great that you are working with pro-bono lawyers on this work but it’s important to build links to NGO and Development networks working in the advocacy or campaigning space to demand changes in legislation at state level but also nationally and internationally. Linking upto organisations such as the Rights in Exile Programme, Amnesty International but also highlighting the work to Trust Conference /Thompson Reuters Foundation may help to highlight the work.

4. What alliances we could establish to increase our impact?

In addition to those mentioned above, linking to other groups working on migrant rights - helps you to build cross movement solidarity and increases your chances of the work staying on the agenda and not just being ‘on trend’ one year and not the next.

You may also want to reach out to SINGA who are opening a business lab in Barcelona - who is able to link up with them and to receive further support and advice.

Photo of Top Manta Project
Team

Dear Swatee Deepak ,

Thank you very much for all your valuable advice and suggestions. We have studied them in detail; we have seen that many of the proposals are already being carried out, but we will take it into account and improve relations with universities, schools and international groups. We are currently working with the Permanent People’ Tribunal (TPP) at European level, we have reached a complaint to the European Parliament in Brussels with them and we will continue to work with them to denounce all injustice, immigration problems and refugees. As a plan on this side, we want to try to pressure politicians to present a repeal of the law through initiatives such as the ”International Day Against Inmigrant Laws” that we want to launch in November with the support of local and European organizations. This month we also have several talks in universities as well as a project with 20 very popular fashion designers who will design 20 exclusive designs for us to be able to put them on sale in our online store. We have also collaborated with the Barcelona Design School (BAU) for new designs. We will study in detail all the extra proposals of alliances that you have provided us to continue expanding our message to the world and achieve great changes. With respect to introducing experiences of the group in our talks and publications, we believe that it is a very valuable material that can make the message better understood to all our audiences. We have tried to introduce these parts in our idea text and graphics and in our business plan, and we will develop them further in the coming months. We are also attending a local event with SINGA this month for further support. We want to thank you for studying our project so well to help us and for your words of support.

All the best,
Top Manta Team

View all comments