OpenIDEO is an open innovation platform. Join our global community to solve big challenges for social good. Sign Up / Login or Learn more

Women's Safety Challenge – Tips for Evaluation

Photo of OpenIDEO

Written by




After an inspiringly productive Refinement phase it's time we turn our attention to the Evaluation phase. While this task is no easy feat it's important that the community weighs in on the impressive Refinement list to evaluate how well they've answered the Challenge criteria. The Amplify Team will soon gather to discuss the shortlist – and the community's answers during the Evaluation phase are an essential piece of the puzzle.

Before we get started, we have asked the Amplify Team to provide clarity around the evaluation criteria and to offer some pointers on making the most of the Evaluation phase:

Does the idea have the potential to impact the lives of low-income women and girls living in urban areas?
Our first Amplify challenge focuses on solutions designed to make life better for low-income women and girls living in urban areas. We’re interested in finding ideas that solve problems associated with the unique conditions of the urban environment – so we’re looking for ideas that are specific to this context.

Likewise, our challenge is also focused on helping women and girls in low-income communities. This means that the solutions we choose for the Shortlist will need to be accessible to women with few resources and limited access to technology.

Does this idea describe a set of next steps and a timeline to accomplish them?
The 52 ideas that advanced to the Refinement stage for this challenge are all at different stages in their path toward implementation. Some of the ideas are very early-stage and may require additional design research and large amounts of testing potential users before the idea is finalized. Some of the other ideas that have advanced to Refinement are quite far along and perhaps just need funding or a bit of design support from IDEO.org to get started with or expand implementation. 

Wherever an idea is in its development, it’s very important during the Evaluation phase that we can envision a clear path toward implementation – even if that path might have many twists and turns along the way. 

What do we mean by a path to implementation? This is a great question. As human-centered designers, we believe testing our ideas with the local community early and often throughout the design process is critical. This is called prototyping. Based upon real feedback from prospective users during prototyping, our ideas are refined and improved. Eventually, our continuous prototyping leads to a refined solution that can be implemented in earnest – a pilot. A pilot can be quite small, but they are important because they provide real-world data and experience to learn from. They are also the first step towards scale. 

The ideas on our final Shortlist can fall anywhere in the spectrum – from prototype-ready to completed pilots poised to scale, but each idea must be able to clearly articulate where they are in this process.

How feasible would it be to implement a pilot of this idea in the next 12-18 months?
Start small and get answers early. This is a goal of both human-centered design and the Amplify program. We know that some of the ideas we support will fail. That’s how innovation works and we are comfortable with this outcome. However, the goal of the Amplify program is to achieve failure (if it occurs) quickly and at a small scale. This way we can either modify the idea, or learn from it and move on, at minimal cost. Can you imagine a pilot version of this idea succeeding or failing in the next 12 to 18 months? Or is it operating on a much longer timeline? 

Time and speed are not the only considerations, either. Not all projects may be of suitable scope for Amplify. Amplify grants are designed to be roughly between $50,000 and $100,000 each, so it is important that this scale of investment could fund at least a pilot of our Shortlist ideas in the next 12 to 18 months.

Does this idea bring a new and fresh approach to the city or region in which it’s set?
Amplify seeks to identify and support innovative solutions to some of the world’s most pressing development issues, so we’re interested in both new and existing ideas. In either instance, however, we’d love your help to understand whether the proposed idea is bringing something unique to the context for which it is designed. If there are existing organisations doing something similar, is this idea taking a new or modified approach? Or perhaps this is an idea that has worked really well in one location (let’s say Nairobi) and is now being tried in an entirely new setting (like Dhaka, maybe). 

How scalable is this across regions and cultures?
As we mentioned earlier, our goal is to support ideas that can be prototyped and piloted quickly and at a small scale in the community for which it is initially intended. That said, we want to invest in ideas that – if they succeed – may be expanded or applied elsewhere as well. This does not mean that the individual or organisation who submitted the idea must be prepared to expand – but it does mean that we’d like to find ideas that could be reasonably adapted to serve additional communities, cities and even countries if all goes well.

While we know that there is no 'one size fits all' solution to women and girls’ safety, help us understand which of the Refinement ideas could have potential in multiple regions of the world and across cultures. 

Overall, how do you feel about this concept?
What do your instincts say? Based upon your personal experiences and what we learned during the Research phase, does this idea have a good chance to be successful? We’ve left some extra space as part of this final question so that you can elaborate a bit on your evaluation.

3.3k 20
Women's Safety Challenge

20 comments

Join the conversation:

Comment
Spam
Photo of t0p game

เว็บ Pdv168 เว็บตรง PD99BET รวม 8 ค่าย คาสิโนดัง นางแบบสุด Sexy แจกไพ่ให้พี่เล่น บาคาร่า หรือ ลูเล็ท แม้กะทั่ง ไฮโล - เสือมังกร และยังมีอีก 7 ค่าย สล็อต อัพเดทเกมใหม่ไว้ที่สุด ยิงปลา ก็มี แทง บอล ก็ได้ สุดยอดจริงๆ เว็บ PDV168 #pdv168 #pd99bet

Spam
Photo of Steve Smith

Leader in homesourced Printer customer services solutions with a secure, proprietary omnichannel platform & tools and a global network of home-based agents.

Spam
Photo of 토토 지식백과

I think you have a good idea after reading this article today. 안전놀이터 I am also impressed to be able to see the author's good thoughts and good writings.. 토토사이트 I'll leave a link. good.I read it well. I'll share this on my blog. It's a great article for everyone to see.. 메이저놀이터 I want to share this article. Thank you. byebye 안전놀이터모음 is good.

Spam
Photo of しちふくじん うまれかわる

เว็บ Pdv168 เว็บตรง PD99BET รวม 8 ค่ายคาสิโนดัง นางแบบสุด Sexy แจกไพ่ให้พี่ๆ รวม 7 ค่ายสล็อต อัพเดทเกมใหม่ไว้ที่สุด #pdv168 #pd99bet

Spam
Photo of 토토 지식백과

hello, good morning Oh, that’s a good article, it’s a very pleasant article. 안전놀이터 Thank you for reading the good thoughts. I will post this on my blog. It has a very good idea. I’ll take it to my post. 안전공원 I'll leave a link. good.I read it well. will take this post to my post and share it. I will leave a link to the source. 메이저놀이터 I want to share this article. Thank you. Have a nice day. call to acction button click now > https://politicadeverdade.com

Spam
Photo of 진수 홍

Oh, that’s a good article, it’s a very pleasant article. 안전놀이터 Thank you for reading the good thoughts. I will post this on my blog. It has a very good idea. I’ll take it to my post. 토토사이트 I'll leave a link. good.I read it well. will take this post to my post and share it. I will leave a link to the source. 메이저놀이터 I want to share this article. Thank you. Have a nice day

Spam
Photo of 동영 이

When I look at your blog site in Safari, 바둑이사이트it looks fine but바둑이게임 when opening in Internet Explorer,골목게임 it has some overlapping.러닝게임 I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!그레잇게임 Other then that,선시티게임 fantastic blog!사설바둑이

Spam
Photo of 토토 지식백과

Hello Wow, I saw the best article today. 안전놀이터 I was moved to see this article. I will post this on my blog. It has a very good idea. I’ll take it to my post. 토토사이트 I'll leave a link. good.I read it well. I would like to leave a link to share this post on my blog. 메이저놀이터 I want to share this article. Thank you. Have a good day again byebye see you agan

Spam
Photo of wang ddu

토토사이트 Sería de gran ayuda para usted. Si tienen tiempo, por favor, miren la información. y que sea una buena información. Muchísimas gracias. https://rafinha18.com

Spam
Photo of wang ddu

Un placer conocerlo. Lo leí muy bien. Creo que hay mucha información valiosa. así que si tienen tiempo, por favor, miren esto. Hay mucha información útil que le ayudará. 메이저놀이터

Spam
Photo of wang ddu

먹튀검증 I saw your writing well. Thank you for good information. I will give you good information, so please refer to it. Thank you. Be full of good things. https://strackattack.com

Spam
Photo of 토토 지식백과

Wow, this is just my style, friend, 안전놀이터 I put everything. This is also included. Wow, it’s really the best. This is a very good article. It has a very good idea. I’ll take it to my post. 토토사이트 good.I read it well. I thought this was a good post, that's why I left a comment I want to share it on my blog, I'll leave a link 메이저놀이터 I want to share this article. On my homepage.

Spam
Photo of 토토 지식백과

Hello friend, I saw this post that you wrote very impressed, that’s a very good post,I also relate to it. I want to share this post on my site. 스포츠중계 and I hope these help. 메리트카지노 good.I read it well. goodbye I saw this article only today. I read it very well. 먹튀폴리스 here good.

Spam
Photo of 토토 지식백과

Hello friend, This article contains very good information. It became a good empathy. Sometimes, these are warm writings that are of great help to our daily lives. 메이저놀이터 I want to share this article. On my best in homepage. 토토사이트 good.I read it well. 안전놀이터 I put everything. This is also included. good good bye

Spam
Photo of cary louder

There are more tips provided for readers who are collecting the ideas so easily and make the page so special in the field and make the page interesting too. e-schooling

Spam
Photo of maria hayden

How Can You Install TurboTax with CD on Your PC? Installation of the TurboTax program on your PC requires you to follow a few steps. What you do is insert the CD you have purchased and when installation prompts appear on your screen, follow them to install TurboTax with CD completely. If any help is needed, get in touch with our expert team.

Spam
Photo of maria hayden

How to Deal with AT&T Email Login Problems? AT&T email problems are mostly common and can all be fixed with a couple of troubleshooting guidelines. If you’re encountering with AT&T Email Login Problems, either you check your login credentials whether they all are correct or contact our executive professional team for immediate help.

Spam
Photo of Chloe Jerrison

One of the most common errors is Canon Printer error code B200, which is a potentially catastrophic error with the device of Canon Pixma Printers. Know the reason why the Canon Printer Error Code B200 occurs, it may have any reasons which occur Canon Pixma Error Code 5012, 5100 error, Here you will how to fix them? Read Carefully!

Spam
Photo of Rose Mery

i read your post it's really great post. view code geass characters

Spam
Photo of Jennifer Winget

women's safety is going to be an important issue. Nowadays many women are harassed by others. we should prevent it strongly. how to turn printer online In this article, the author explained the women's safety challenges. All are please read this article at least once.